A Forum for Ideas
News • Books • Writing
Interact, share ideas, and take action!

A Forum for Ideas is a place to discuss ideas and then act to put those ideas into motion. Each month a new topic will be introduced. There will be daily discussion questions to spark conversations, a quote of the day, and much more. Come join the discussion and start sharing your Ideas!
Interested? Want to learn more about the community?

Learn more first
Maxim Gorky - Creatures That Once Were Men - Section II

Section II begins by introducing a new series of characters into the story. These are the regulars who stay at the dosshouse. Each has a unique story. One of those mentioned is a boy that they called Kuvalda Meteor.

Here is an excerpt from his introduction to the story:

"Boy! What business have you here on this earth?"
The boy answered boldly and stoutly:
"I am a barefooted tramp. . . ."
"You are a fool!" decided Aristid Kuvalda. "what are you knocking about here for? You are of absolutely no use to us . . . Do you drink vodki? . . . No? . . . Well, then, can you steal?" Again, "No." "Go away, learn, and come back again when you know something, and are a man. . . ."
The youngster smiled. "No. I shall live with you."
"Why?"
"Just because. . . ."

After Gorky finished introducing the new cast of characters he notes:
“The above were the chief members of the Captain's company, and he called them with kind-hearted sarcasm "Creatures that once were Men." For though there were men who had experienced as much of the bitter irony of fate as these men; yet they were not fallen so low.”
I am curious to see how Gorky works these characters into the story, especially the boy. The boy doesn’t drink and therefore is not a prisoner to that vice. Yet he chooses to stay at the dosshouse. I also find it interesting how Gorky notes that other men had suffered as much as these men but still avoided the same fate as these men. Some men become victims of their circumstances and others rise through them.
The story next shifts to Tyapa, who was an old man who was described as “tall and angular, he kept his head in such a position that his chin touched his breast.” We learn that he walked that way because someone had once tried to slit his throat because of a rumor stating Tyapa had a hidden collection of money. Tyapa spends a great deal of time reading his old bible.
One Sunday while reading the bible the following exchange occurs:
"Oh, you drunken blackguard," said Kuvalda to him, "what do you understand of it?"
"Nothing, wizard! I don't understand anything, and I do not read any books . . . But I read. . . ."
"Therefore you are a fool . . ." said the Captain, decidedly.”

Tyapa often goes to the teacher to ask questions about the Bible. He is particularly concerned about who he is descended from.
“You are learned . . . Tell me, then, whose descendants are we? Are we Babylonians, or who are we?"
"We are Slavs, Tyapa," said the teacher, and attentively awaited his answer, wishing to understand him.
"Speak to me from the Bible. There are no such men there."
Then the teacher began criticizing the Bible. The old man listened, and interrupted him after a long while.
"Stop . . . Wait! That means that among people known to God there are no Russians? We are not known to God? Is it so? God knew all those who are mentioned in the Bible . . . He destroyed them by sword and fire, He destroyed their cities; but He also sent prophets to teach them.
That means that He also pitied them. He scattered the Jews and the Tartars . . . But what about us? Why have we prophets no longer?"

Tyapa is trying to wrap his head around how the Bible relates to Russians. Since Russians are not named in the Bible he feels that God must not love them as much as he does those named in the Bible, but he wants him to. He is also striving to understand where the prophets of today have gone. This is an opportunity for a profoundly deep theological discussion about the nature of God but the teacher cannot unders what Tyapa is trying to convey. He sees it as the ramblings of an old drunk man. He struggles to answer Tyapa and eventually breaks down in tears. Tyapa doesn’t understand this reaction and tells him he needs to get a real job.

The teacher and Tyapa became friends after this interaction. This surprised the others who stayed At the dosshouse. Gorky notes:
“From this day they became friends, and the "creatures that once were men," seeing them together, said: "The teacher is friendly with Tyapa . . . He wishes his money. Kuvalda must have put this into his head . . . To look about to see where the old man's fortune is. . . ."
Probably they did not believe what they said. There was one strange thing about these men, namely, that they painted themselves to others worse than they actually were. A man who has good in him does not mind sometimes showing his worse nature.”

This last sentiment is interesting. Surrounded by others in dire conditions they try to make themselves seem worse than they really are. I wonder if in the presence of others who are well off they would have tried to act better than they actually are. Perhaps under different circumstances they would make entirely different choices. The difference between a positive influence and a negative influence can be immense.
This is how section II ends. I feel like something is building up that will probably occur in the next couple of sections. I look forward to seeing what happens next. Let me know your thoughts on Section II.

Interested? Want to learn more about the community?

Learn more first
What else you may like…
Videos
Posts
Articles
William Wilberforce

William Wilberforce has been called an agitator for his commitment to ending the slave trade. One of his well known speeches on the subject was given on May 12, 1789.

00:00:08
Cardinal Richelieu Statesman or Subversive?

Cardinal Richelieu has been hailed as a great statesman and as a subversive authoritarian. Depending on who you talk to he was a man needed to strengthen the monarchy in France, or he was a tyrant seeking personal power. Next week I will have a book review that may shed more light on Cardinal Richelieu.

00:00:08
Lenin Drafting What is to Be Done

When Lenin was working on his major writing projects he would often pace across the room formulating the ideas that he would write down by saying them out loud. Once he had the idea for what he wanted to write he would often repeat the idea to Nadezhda Krupskaya, who would provide feedback. Once this process was complete he would then write the ideas down.

Here is an AI rendering of what that might have looked like when he was drafting What is to be Done.

00:00:08
The Role of Subversion

This month this community will focus on political subversion. What is subversion? When is it justified? What is the interplay between subversion and agitation? These are some of the topics to be discussed this month.

Quote of the Day

“You get used to the despot’s shortcomings, when they are not great vices, and the change of an autocratic ruler leads to involuntary fear.”

Sergei Trubetskoi

Question

Can subversion and heroic sacrifice go hand in hand?

My FOREX Journey
An Idea Begins to Form
Inflation was soaring, talks of recession were incessant and I had some money that hadn’t been spent on bills yet. It was time to invest. But what would I invest in?  The stock market didn’t seem appealing. The price of bitcoin was dropping and as much as I would like to own a game used Bryce
Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals