On the night of March 5, 1770, a crowd gathered around a British sentry outside Boston’s Custom House. Tensions had been building since British troops arrived in the city. As people shouted and threw snowballs and other objects, Captain Thomas Preston arrived with soldiers to back up the sentry. The soldiers fired into the crowd, killing five people, including Crispus Attucks. Witnesses disagreed about whether Preston had ordered his men to fire. Preston and eight soldiers faced murder charges.
When John Adams and Josiah Quincy Jr. agreed to defend the accused, the criticism reached them in different ways. Adams later wrote in his diary that taking the case brought him anxiety and public condemnation. Quincy heard from his own father, who wrote that he was deeply distressed by the bitter criticism he had heard directed at his son. Even within Quincy’s family, the two sides of the case were represented in court. His older brother Samuel helped prosecute the soldiers. Quincy also had supporters. He told his father that several Patriot leaders, including John Hancock, had urged him to take the case.
The lawyers asked the juries to weigh the evidence in a city that was still angry about the deaths. Preston was acquitted in a separate trial. Six of the eight soldiers were acquitted, and the other two were convicted of manslaughter.
In “Dusk,” Sydney Carton is looking for a way to help after the tribunal has already sentenced Darnay to death. Adams and Quincy could put evidence before a jury. Carton can urge Doctor Manette to speak to officials who were willing to listen to him the day before. In private, Carton agrees with Mr. Lorry that the effort offers little hope. He still believes Darnay’s life is worth the attempt.
Adams and Quincy risked public criticism to give the accused a fair defense. Carton urges one more attempt to save a life even though he doubts it will work. In each case, what made the effort worth making before anyone knew how it would turn out?
Great literature should do more than entertain us. It should provide a roadmap to improving our lives.
In A Tale of Two Cities, Charles Dickens introduced readers to Sydney Carton, one of literature's most compelling and deeply flawed characters. Dickens also gives him an unusual title: the Jackal.
His struggles raise questions that remain relevant today.
Are we defined by our past mistakes? Can we overcome our weaknesses? What separates the people we are from the people we could become?
Lessons From the Jackal is a 25-day character study exploring these questions through Sydney Carton’s life, decisions, relationships, and personal development.
This is not a traditional course on A Tale of Two Cities. Our reading assignments will focus specifically on Carton, with sufficient background provided to understand his story. No previous knowledge of the novel is necessary.
Each day will feature selected readings, historical comparisons, reflection questions, discussions, and practical challenges ...
“Can you, of all the people who love her, bear to see her so?”
After Lucie says goodbye to Darnay, she faints. Carton, who has been watching from among the spectators, steps forward. He carries her to a coach and takes her home. When little Lucie sees him, she throws her arms around him and begs him to help her mother and save her father.
Why does she place so much trust in Carton? We remember that he was the first stranger to whom she held out her arms. Years later, she reaches for him again in one of her family’s darkest moments. Is this the optimism of a child, or has she seen something in Carton that others have missed?
Before leaving, Carton bends down, kisses Lucie, and whispers, “A life you love.” Lucie is still unconscious, but her daughter is close enough to hear him. She remembers those words long enough to tell them to her own grandchildren. What might Carton mean by them?
Carton then urges Doctor Manette to use whatever influence he still has with the tribunal. A short ...
In March 1793, France’s National Convention set up a special court in Paris to try people accused of acting against the Revolution. The court, which became known as the Revolutionary Tribunal, heard cases in the Grand’Chambre of the old royal palace. The room was renamed the Salle de la Liberté, or “Hall of Liberty.” Marie Antoinette was tried there later that year. The tribunal’s verdicts were final, so a person who was convicted had no right to ask a higher court to review the decision.
That helps explain what Carton is asking of Doctor Manette in “Dusk.” With Darnay’s execution set for the following afternoon, the Doctor plans to speak directly to the tribunal’s president, the prosecutor, and others who might listen to him. His standing among those officials gives him a chance to be heard. Carton believes that chance is worth taking, even with so little time and so little reason to expect success.
The Palais de Justice complex still stands on the Île de la Cité ...